A reflection for Sunday 16th February 2025 Epiphany III by the Rev'd David Warnes
I wonder how many of you, many decades ago, were caught out in some naughtiness and heard one of your elders saying “Woe betide you if you do that again!” Don’t worry - I’m not asking for a show of hands. That recollection came to me when I turned to today’s Gospel, in which Luke has Jesus use the word woe several times.
The next thought that struck me is that it isn’t at first clear how our three Bible readings fit together. There’s clearly a link between the curses and blessings of which Jeremiah speaks and our Gospel passage from Luke in which Jesus contrasts those who are blessed and those whom he addresses using the word woe. Today’s Epistle, that passage from the first letter to the Corinthians in which Paul asserts the truth and the significance of the Resurrection, seems at first hearing unconnected to the other two readings, yet it is the key which unlocks their importance for us and which enables us to see the contrast between them.
That there is a contrast between Jeremiah and Jesus becomes clear when Jeremiah’s curses are contrasted with Jesus’ use of the word woe. The Hebrew word which Jeremiah uses means bitter, savage condemnation with no possibility of forgiveness. When an older relative said “Woe betide you…” in response to our juvenile misdemeanours, what they meant and what Jeremiah is saying was: “you’ll be punished!” When Jesus speaks of woe he is expressing sorrow. One might legitimately translate Luke 6, verse 24 like this:
“I sorrow for those of you who are rich, for you have received your consolation.”
Jesus isn’t threatening punishment. He’s expressing something much more subtle, he’s blending two things which we sinful humans find it difficult to hold together - judgement and empathy. Much that is wrong with our public discourse and our discussion of social issues stems from our inability to understand that judgement and empathy aren’t polar opposites, that they can and must work together.
The judgement in Jesus’ words about the rich is clear - they have received their consolation - they have got what they wanted, but they haven’t wanted the right things. Their desire has been misdirected. The same applies to all the others about whom Jesus uses the word woe - the seekers after material comfort, entertainment and popularity. And how contemporary those desires seem. Yet the judgement is blended with compassion.
“I sorrow for those of you who are rich, for you have received your consolation.”
Jesus’ approach poses questions that we need to ask of ourselves. Am I being judgmental in a way which lacks compassion? Am I going to the opposite extreme and allowing compassion to elbow aside moral judgement. To wrestle with such issues is part of our Christian calling. As we look forward to Lent, these questions might be a fruitful agenda for self-examination every time we watch or listen to a news bulletin or engage with social media.
And then we turn to the Beatitudes, the blessings that Jesus confers on the poor, the hungry, the sad, the marginalised and the persecuted. On one level he is radically attacking the view which prevailed in those days that wealth and happiness were signs of God’s approval - and not just in those days, for what we now call the Prosperity Gospel still finds expression in some Christian denominations. Jesus is also demonstrating solidarity with those who suffer. He has no fixed abode, no regular source of income; he experiences grief, sorrow and temptation. He knows what it means to be unpopular and he will die like a slave or a criminal on account of his actions and beliefs.
The Beatitudes are statements of faith, not descriptions of current experience. They seem to invite a negative response from those to whom they are addressed, those whose lives are difficult, diminished, uncomfortable or imperilled - those who have reasons not to feel blessed and yet they are also an invitation to trust in God, to have the trust of which Jeremiah speaks:
Blessed are those who trust in the LORD, whose trust is the LORD.
And that is why the compilers of the Lectionary chose today’s reading from 1 Corinthians to point us from Jeremiah to the Gospel. The Resurrection of Jesus is the basis of our trust in God. Without the Resurrection there would be no Gospel to read, no Church in which it is preached and shared and the Beatitudes would, with all the teaching of Jesus, be lost to posterity.
Those concerning whom Christ expresses woe have been captivated by the things of this world. Those whom Christ calls blessed have been distressed by the adversity they have experienced. Our calling is to have faith not in ourselves, nor in our experiences and circumstances, whether good or bad. Faith isn’t about what happens to me, it’s about what happened to Jesus Christ. Through Lent, which begins in two and half weeks, and Holy Week and the commemoration of Christ’s passion we look forward to Easter and to the Resurrection, God’s vindication and affirmation of the blessings and promises in today’s Gospel.